Aileen Wuornos: Self-Defense, Trauma, and the Trial That Branded Her a Monster

The story of Aileen Wuornos raises difficult questions about prostitution, childhood trauma, self-defense, mental illness, and whether her jury ever understood her world

Aileen Wuornos Florida Department of Corrections mugshot
Aileen Wuornos, pictured in a Florida Department of Corrections mugshot. Public domain.

A feminist by the name of Phyllis Chesler had behind-the-scenes access to Aileen Wuornos. Phyllis is a feminist leader, a psychotherapist, and an expert courtroom witness.

She wanted to testify in Aileen’s defense to point out the dangers and traumas that are involved with being a prostitute, especially for someone as young as Aileen was when she started selling her body.

In one of her books, she goes on to say that the bullets Aileen used to kill her victims were sent to shatter the silence on the violence that women endure during prostitution.

So, in a strange way, she actually deemed Aileen to be some sort of advocate for female sex workers.

Chesler says that her involvement in the case and wanting to help Wuornos stemmed from a single question:

Does a sex worker have the right to defend her own life?

Her answer was “probably not,” and it's somewhat agreeable.

There are dozens of cases where prostitutes have claimed to be sexually assaulted, and because of their line of work, no one believed them. Especially the police.

A lot of sex-working women would rather settle the score on their own than go to the police because they know it’ll be a dead-end street.

The Trauma Behind Aileen Wuornos

Phyllis believed that Aileen suffered from a form of trauma called battered woman syndrome.

Chesler wanted to explore whether the concept of battered woman syndrome could be extended to women who had experienced violence while working as prostitutes. Her proposed defense team included those who are experts in prostitution, violence against prostitutes, child abuse, battery, rape trauma, and other areas of psychology and trauma. However, none of those experts were called during the guilt phase of Wuornos's trial.

Based on the way she was raised and the way she was treated by her own family members, Wuornos never stood a chance in life.

Her father was diagnosed with schizophrenia, and based on statements from friends and family, it isn't hard to believe that Aileen suffered from the same mental illness.

Aileen never met her father (Leo Pittman). He was later convicted of sexual crimes against a child and died by suicide in prison. Her mother, Diane Wuornos, abandoned Aileen and her brother, Keith Wuornos, when Aileen was young, leaving her to be raised by her maternal grandparents. Court records also document allegations of physical and verbal abuse in her childhood, as well as the rape that left her pregnant at fourteen.

None of this excuses what she eventually did.

But it does matter when we're trying to understand how someone becomes who they become.

The Last Resort in Port Orange Florida
The Last Resort in Port Orange, Florida, a bar associated with Aileen Wuornos. Photo by Ken Lund/Wikimedia Commons.

When asked why none of her expert witnesses were called to testify in Aileen's defense, Phyllis stated that Aileen’s public defender would never sit down and talk with her team.

Afterwards, Phyllis learned that the majority of Tricia Jenkins experience was defending male rapists and male serial killers.

Aileen was also the most difficult client Tricia had ever had to defend.

Since she didn’t know how to save herself, Aileen made it harder for everyone else to save her.

She didn’t trust anyone. She was too afraid of being hurt again.

If her public defender had called upon some of the expert feminists on the team that Phyllis put together, Aileen would have at least had a fighting chance in one of her cases.

The jury would have also gotten the chance to hear testimonies from women who were sex workers, just like Aileen, and had argued self-defense and won.

They never got to hear the phrase "self-defense," which is unbelievable because Aileen was adamant about it from the very beginning.

She repeatedly claimed that she had acted in self-defense, including during her videotaped confession. Chesler argued that important portions of Wuornos's statements about self-defense were edited out before the jury saw the confession.

The court didn’t care that one of the complaints in Aileen's appeal was the non-calling of any expert witnesses.

The Florida Supreme Court ultimately upheld her conviction and death sentence. Wuornos had argued, among other things, that evidence concerning Richard Mallory and her self-defense claim had not been properly handled. The court rejected those arguments.

Richard Mallory and the Self-Defense Question

Richard Mallory, Aileen Wuornos first known victim
Richard Mallory, Aileen Wuornos' first known victim, was 51 when he was killed in Florida in November 1989. Photo via Wuornos's Case: Richard Mallory.

The fact that her first victim had been drinking was also part of the controversy surrounding her case.

Mallory had a significant criminal history that later became central to arguments about what the jury should have known about him. According to Chesler, Mallory had spent years at Patuxent Prison in Maryland as a sex offender, and his records described him as having serious problems with sexual impulses and violence.

Yet and still, that history was not presented to the jury in the way Wuornos's defense had wanted.

Mallory had a long history of violence towards women, hence why he spent years in a Maryland correctional institution.

If those facts had been brought up during her trial, Wuornos may have gotten a lesser sentence in her case vs. Mallory.

The Florida Supreme Court later explained that Wuornos's own testimony was the only eyewitness account of the actual killing and that, if the jury had believed her version of events, it could have concluded that she lacked premeditated intent or even acquitted her. But the court also held that the evidence of the other killings and other circumstances could properly be used to challenge her self-defense claim.

With an already troubled past and a lot of mental health issues, Aileen put her own practices into effect after her incident with Mallory.

She stated that if a guy wanted to do things she didn’t want to, or if they got too frisky or too rough, she killed them.

No questions asked.

A lot of things were out of sync in Aileen’s mind, and that’s something that expert witnesses could have helped get across to the jury. Her level of comprehension didn't exceed that of her early high school years. Some even questioned how much she retained before high school.

There were defense psychologists who testified during the penalty phase of the trial. They discussed Wuornos's mental health, including diagnoses involving borderline personality disorder and antisocial personality disorder. But the experts Chesler had assembled to discuss prostitution, trauma, abuse, and violence against prostitutes were not called during the guilt phase.

A Jury That Didn't Know Her World

Empty prison corridor
An empty prison corridor. Photo by Maia Fotografia via Pexels.

None of those people in the jury box were her peers.

That may sound harsh, but death-penalty cases have a very specific jury-selection process. In Florida, jurors in capital cases had to be “death qualified,” meaning they had to be willing to consider the death penalty as a possible punishment. After finding Wuornos guilty of killing Richard Mallory, the jury unanimously recommended that she receive the death penalty.

Her trial was biased from the very beginning.

Aileen didn’t fit in with them, so they looked at her crimes and immediately wanted her erased from their world.

There wasn’t a single sex worker on her jury. There wasn't one person who came from the same environment as Aileen. The jury was selected to have her thrown to the wolves and judged based on the lifestyle she lived.

The jury was also allowed to hear evidence about the other killings under Florida's Williams Rule. That became important because Wuornos was on trial for Richard Mallory's murder, but evidence concerning the other killings was used by the prosecution to establish a pattern and challenge her self-defense claim.

To add even more weight to Aileen’s shoulders, the prosecutor, John Tanner, had a very negative outlook towards sex workers.

Phyllis Chesler specifically criticized Tanner's portrayal of Wuornos as a “predatory prostitute” and argued that the prosecution's presentation relied heavily on stereotypes about women, prostitutes, and female sexuality.

It could have been argued that Tanner went after Aileen as hard as he did, not only because she was a woman, but because he had a strong dislike for "prostitutes".

Person sitting alone on a bench

The prosecution's characterization of Wuornos as a “predatory prostitute” is documented, and the question of how much her gender and occupation influenced the way she was perceived is absolutely worth discussing.

In the end, the fight ultimately came down to gender and prostitutes.

What the Jury Never Got to Hear

The jury in Aileen’s case was never educated on what the effects were for a woman who had been prostituting for more than twenty years, or what it meant for her whenever one of her Johns got too physical.

A woman could never know what a man would do to her in that situation, and she would only be left with a split second to make a decision on how to defend herself.

Expert witnesses could have easily pointed out these arguments to the jury.

But the jury was never put in the position to ask themselves how they would react if they were in Aileen's position.

The only thing drilled into their heads during her trial was that Aileen was a menace to society, and she needed to be put to death.

They also should have only focused on one murder at a time, rather than arguing all seven murders in one case.

But legally, that's not quite what happened.

Wuornos's first and only full murder trial was for Richard Mallory's killing. She was not tried for all seven murders together. Instead, evidence concerning the other killings was admitted during the Mallory trial under Florida's Williams Rule. She later pleaded guilty or no contest to the other murder charges and received additional death sentences.

They would have never believed that Aileen acted out of self-defense with Richard Mallory because they had already been told about the other murders.

It can be believed that Aileen was beyond human grace.

There was no way for her to be saved. Even if her claim of self-defense was true, she was already labeled as a monster.

She believed she was a monster as well, since there was some sort of chemical imbalance in her brain.

She may have indeed had a good side to her, according to statements made by her best friend, Dawn Botkins, but unfortunately, her bad side outweighed all of her good judgment.

She was too far gone, and, to her own discretion, she did not want to be reeled in.

She enjoyed her life.

Aileen Wuornos Wasn't Like Other Serial Killers

Man running on beach next to pier
A man running along a Florida beach. Photo by Brandon Ricketts via Pexels.

Aileen wasn’t like most male serial killers, and certainly nothing like any female serial killers.

There are tons of women who have been brought up the same exact way as she was, but not all of them have turned to the same life of crime that Aileen had.

Many of them run away from home, turn to prostitution, and even get involved in petty or violent crimes, but not all of them become serial killers.

Severe, prolonged childhood trauma plays a huge part in the background of a lot of serial killers.

Even some non-serial killers have a traumatic past.

Oftentimes, when people grow up in certain environments, they start to believe that the way they were raised is the norm.

For most of us, we know better than to believe that's true.

But for victims of abuse, like Wuornos, they really believe that their lives are normal.

Aileen's childhood was undeniably chaotic.

Her mother abandoned her when she was young. She was raised by her grandparents. She reported physical and sexual abuse, and she became pregnant after being raped at fourteen. She eventually left home and lived on the streets, where she survived through prostitution and other crimes.

None of that makes murder acceptable. But it gives us context.

Sometimes context is the part of a true-crime story people don't want to hear.

In several interviews, Aileen is seen and heard talking about her victims as if they were nothing.

It was almost as if none of her wrongdoings were actually wrong.

She really believed that she was in the right and that she should suffer no consequences for what she had done because the men she killed were already doing something wrong.

Her statements changed over time. She consistently claimed self-defense in important portions of her story, but she also made statements that contradicted that position. The Florida Supreme Court specifically noted inconsistencies among her confessions.

Tyria Moore

Directional signs at night
Directional signs at night. Photo by Stephen Leonardi via Pexels.

Tyria, a woman Aileen became infatuated with, tried to save her at one point.

But even she had grown tired and afraid of Aileen's outbursts, and eventually washed her hands of their relationship.

Tyria and Aileen were lovers for several years. Moore eventually cooperated with police during the investigation, and her involvement became an important part of the case against Wuornos.

Violence, in a sense, was the way that Aileen showed love.

It was all she knew from a very young age, and it stuck with her up until the day she was executed in a Florida State Prison for the robberies and murders of seven men.

She claimed self-defense in all seven cases.

Wuornos ultimately received six death sentences for six murders. She was never tried for the killing of Peter Siems, whose body was never found. She was executed by lethal injection at Florida State Prison on October 9, 2002.

From her perspective, she was getting revenge for all the times she had been abused as a child and taken advantage of as a sex worker.

Oftentimes, female children who have been sexually abused don’t value themselves or their bodies.

That was Aileen.

She felt like, since no one else respected her and her body, why should she?

So, even though she was getting paid to have sexual relations with the men she murdered, in her eyes, they were still taking advantage of her because she was a prostitute.

Maybe that's the part of Aileen Wuornos's story that people still struggle with the most. You can look at what she did and call it murder. You can call her a serial killer.

You can look at the seven men, the guns, the robberies, the confessions, the contradictions, and the death sentences; all of that is true.

But understanding how somebody got there doesn't mean you have to excuse what they did.

Sometimes, understanding the monster means being willing to look at the person before the monster ever existed.

────────────

The Public Note.
Everything Worth Noting.

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post