Dear, JT

Did Caresha sacrifice her friendship with JT for fame? A closer look at the City Girls breakup, Yung Miami's solo career, and the price of putting fame before friendship

All fame and fortune aside, City Gworls Yung Miami is a force to be reckoned with!

Although she already had ties to the industry long before the City Girls—her mother, Keenya Young, being connected and rapper Trina being her godmother—Caresha Brownlee put in the work and earned her stripes.

She grew up in Opa Locka, Florida, somewhere between the struggle and luxury. Because her mother was respected in the streets and dated men with money, she had a more stable and supported upbringing than her groupmate. Her outgoing personality made her popular with the rappers on her own, but she wasn't necessarily pursuing a rap career herself. A girl just wanted to have fun.

Jatavia "JT" Johnson Was Dealt a Different Set of Cards

Wikimedia Commons · CC BY 3.0 · Original image


She grew up bouncing between Carol City and Liberty City, two of the roughest parts of Miami. She was reportedly one of 16-18 siblings, and her mother had a drug addiction that landed her in jail when JT was around five years old. She stated that the loss of her mother deeply impacted her childhood, and she felt like the black sheep living amongst her father's blended family.

She moved in with her father and stepmother during that time, and it was her father who had introduced her to music. He assembled a sibling rap group called The Protegees, and that's where JT discovered she had a natural ability for writing rhymes.

Her father was a drug dealer who made a significant amount of money and stepped up to take care of her, even when she moved out as a teen. But he often painted her mother in a bad light because he disliked her so much, which made JT feel like he disliked her too. Especially since she didn't look like her stepmother and their children.

Although she describes their relationship as strained and distant, she does acknowledge that he did what he had to do as her father. Her resentment toward him stems from when she moved in with her aunt at 13 and realized her aunt was struggling; she wanted to move back home, but he refused.

You made your bed, lay in it.

 

How the City Girls Were Born

The duo met as teenagers during the Myspace era and clicked—something like opposites attract.

Caresha was fun and bubbly, while JT was a little more serious and hardcore because of her upbringing.

JT admits that when she saw how popular and lit Yung Miami was, she wanted to be her bestie. Everything from matching outfits to sneaking out to party on teen night made them inseparable. JT would even stay at Yung Miami's house a lot of nights to escape her troubled life.

It wasn't until 2017 that rap became a part of their friendship.

JT wanted to record a diss track called "F*** That N***a" about her ex-boyfriend, and even though Yung Miami wasn't really a rapper, she asked her to write a verse anyway.

As a writer and musician myself, I know how important it is to have your dawg jump on a track! It's something you're passionate about and you want to share the moment with them, period.

"F*** That N***a" went viral on SoundCloud, snatching 100,000 views in one week. Their buzz caught the attention of Coach K, one of the founders of QC Records, and prompted him to send the labels manager on the prowl.

At first, the City Girls were stern on staying independent—priding themselves on their hustle mentality and getting it out the mud. But after learning that Quality Control was the biggest rising label in hip hop, they changed their minds and became label mates with artists like The Migos, Lil Baby, and Lil Yachty at the end of 2017.

In May 2018, they dropped their debut mixtape, Period, and that was the start of all their trouble.

JT Goes to Jail Just As Their Careers Take Off

Photo by K - Photography

If you're anything like me—a conspiracy theorist—everything from this point on will make the most sense to you and possibly put you in the mind of JT herself.

JT had legal trouble involving credit card fraud. She was arrested shortly after the release of their first single and ultimately received a two-year federal prison sentence.

If you believe in or know anything about the illuminati, you know there's always some kind of sacrifice before or after a significant rise to stardom. While Caresha didn't hit Michael Jackson's level of fame overnight, she did become the hood's version of Beyoncé.

Just as the group was experiencing its biggest breakthrough, JT had to report to prison.

She began serving her sentence in July 2018.

Think about that for a second.

One half of the hottest emerging female rap duo was behind bars while the other was suddenly responsible for keeping the entire operation moving.

When the legendary Drizzy Drake dropped In My Feelings, featuring the City Girls, both of their verses were heavily chopped from the final version of the track, though Miami was present alongside the superstar in the video.

A still from In My Feelings video

She can be seen wearing a custom-made FREE JT jacket to keep JT's name alive, but we all know what they say about wolves in sheep's clothing.

Not saying that's what Yung Miami represented.

However, from JT's standpoint—feeling like the black sheep in her childhood and also discarded from their group—there is a certain level of relevance.

What Caresha Did While JT Was Incarcerated

She didn't stop working. Yung Miami became the public face of the City Girls.

  • Performed at clubs and music events.
  • Promoted their music.
  • Appeared in videos without JT.
  • Continued doing interviews and press.
  • Helped keep the group's name relevant.
  • Built relationships and visibility within the industry.

In her 2018 interview with The FADER, Caresha talked about going to strip clubs and paying DJs to play their music. She insisted that since the City Girls had a buzz going on, she didn't want it to slip away just because JT was incarcerated.

She explained that since she views JT as her sister and best friend, she saw whatever money she made as a way to hold her down while she was gone.

The City Girls continued releasing music, including their second project, Girl Code, in November 2018.

The album featured Cardi B on "Twerk." Then came "Act Up," which became one of their signature records.

While Caresha could have easily capitalized on the attention by launching a solo career during JT's incarceration, she later explained that she didn't want to do that because of the friendship and agreement they shared.

In a 2020 Los Angeles Times interview, she described keeping the group alive as something she needed to do because JT was her family.

This is important because it complicates the argument that Caresha was deliberately trying to leave JT behind from the beginning.

At least publicly, she presented herself as someone holding things together for both of them.

JT comes home: October 2019

After serving 15 months in the state pen, JT transitioned to a halfway house in Atlanta.

Her travel restrictions made it hard for her to pick up where she left off, but she did drop a musical statement after her release on a solo track called First Day Out.

She wanted the world to know she was back and better. But the music industry is like a revolving door: when one person exists, another one enters.

Since Caresha had spent more than a year doing interviews, performing, appearing in music videos, and becoming recognizable as the face of the group, JT had returned to a fanbase that moved on without her.

That doesn't mean Caresha is to blame. It simply means the world stops for no one.

Although Caresha felt like she was doing what a sister would do by keeping the group alive, JT didn't quite see it that way.

JT talked about how hard it was to adjust to the attention and criticism after her incarceration, especially since her role in the group was negatively impacted by the time she spent behind bars.

The City Girls did reunite professionally, releasing their album, City on Lock, in 2020. However, Caresha's identity had far expanded beyond the music by then.

She was in a relationship with Diddy, and in June 2022, she launched her own fan-favorite REVOLT series, Caresha Please, with Diddy as her first guest. And we all know the dark role Diddy plays in the industry.

If you don't, I suggest you stick your head into the rabbit hole.

Did JT Become Jealous of Caresha?

On an emotional episode of Caresha Please, featuring JT and Saucy Santana, Caresha made it a point to let JT know that she would have never wanted to become a star without her.

While they started out as the City Girls, Caresha Please was Caresha's own brand.

She was getting individual recognition as a host and media personality. She was developing relationships with celebrities and becoming a recognizable face outside of music. Much like Beyonce after her split from several groupmates.

JT also had individual ambitions, but their respective career paths were becoming increasingly different.

Their fanbase played a huge part in that.

Whenever one member of the duo started receiving a different kind of attention, the comparisons become inevitable.

Who is more popular? Who has more opportunities? Who is more marketable? Who is carrying the group?

In 2024, the tension became public.

JT released "Sideways" and "No Bars," which fans interpreted as her taking shots at Caresha.

Caresha responded on social media, and the two exchanged words publicly.

JT later went on the Keke Palmer Podcast and talked about how she was hurt by the way things played out.

She said their beef was because of communication errors and egos on both parts and later said that they had squashed it.


The Actual Fall of the City Girls

By 2023 the divide was harder to ignore.

The City Girls released their third studio album, RAW, in October 2023.

Unfortunately, the album didn't perform as strongly as their earlier projects.

But the album wasn't their only issue. What was once natural chemistry started to feel forced.

Their lives had moved in different directions with JT spending time in L.A. developing her own musical identity, and Caresha being heavily focused on continuing to build her own celebrity brand.

In an interview with Complex, Caresha said the album was a flop because they were in different places mentally and professionally. Everything they once did together, they had started to do separately—separate dressing rooms, separate glam squads, and separate routines while on tour.

In her own separate interview with Complex, JT simply stated that the decision to go their separate ways was mutual and that there were no hard feelings. They had simply grown apart.

But was that the truth?

November 2026: Where Things Stand Now

On October 23, 2026, Caresha released her debut solo album, Watch Dis!

One of the songs is titled "Dear JT" where she's addressing their friendship directly.

She talks about their early days before the fame, before the City Girls, and before JT was taken away from her. She acknowledges their public fallout and takes accountability for the role she played in the way their friendship ended up.

She also acknowledged that losing a longtime friend wasn't easy.

More recently, Caresha indicated that they hadn't spoken in approximately two years, but she wasn't ruling out a possible reunion.

In My Humblest Opinion

Caresha carried the group.

She's the hood's Beyonce.

While JT was always crowned the most lyrical of the two, Caresha didn't let that stop her from fulfilling her duty as a sister and keeping their group alive when JT couldn't.

I understand egos, feeling left out, and the darkness of the industry. But I also understand sacrifice.

Ronnie said it best,

A still from the Players club

You gotta use what you got to get what you want. 

That's exactly what Caresha did. But she did it with style, grace, and loyalty.

Regardless of how JT feels or what the real outsiders might've put into her head, she was Caresha's Kelly Rowland. She might've felt left behind because of her childhood trauma, but her sister never stop putting on for her.

They had their differences, they exchanged words when things got heated, but that's what sisters do.

In the end, Caresha set her pride aside and made an effort to take it back to where it all started.

Miami.

My question to you is: If having the crown means looking around and realizing some of the people, relationships, and pieces of yourself are no longer there, is the crown still worth wearing?


────────────

The Public Note.
Everything Worth Noting.

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post